On a ’90s Halloween night, the mask was always the first problem. It was flimsy plastic, molded into a Ninja Turtle, a Power Ranger, or a vaguely Jasmine-shaped princess. The eyeholes never lined up with your actual eyes. And the only thing tethering your fun disguise to your head was one thin elastic string haphazardly stapled to the sides. It was always one tug away from snapping. The other options were homemade before DIY was cool—cardboard boxes, old sheets, or maybe even a garbage bag—and they weren’t any more breathable.
By the end of the first block, your breath had fogged the inside of the mask and pooled into a warm little puddle at your chin. No matter what costume you wore, you were sweating all over because your parents wouldn’t let you outside without your puffy winter coat on to protect against the 38-degree night air. (So kids today do have one thing going for them—global warming.)
But none of that really mattered. You had a pillowcase, a pack of friends, and about three glorious, unsupervised hours. Somewhere out there was the full-size candy bar house, and you were going to find it.
That was ’90s Halloween: no $300 skeleton, no “spooky season” starting in August. Just nights you’d still remember 30 years later.
TL;DR
Why ’90s Halloween was better: homemade costumes · spooky-not-scary decorations · full-size candy bars · Hocus Pocus on repeat · Goosebumps from the book fair How to bring it back: throw a ’90s-themed party · dig out blow molds and paper die-cuts · stream the classics · dress as ’90s pop culture · stock old-school candy · cue up a spooky ’90s playlist
Costumes were better when they came from a closet (or a cardboard box)
’90s Halloween costumes were cheap, simple, and charmingly imperfect—whether they were homemade or came from a drugstore box.
A lot of Halloween costumes from the ’90s were built from whatever was in the house. A bedsheet with two eyeholes made a ghost. If your parents were crafty, you might get a cardboard-box robot with dryer-vent arms, which you’d then have to wear sideways through every front door. And a garbage bag and some face paint made…something.
The other option was the drugstore boxed costume: a printed vinyl smock that tore if you looked at it wrong and that flimsy plastic mask. Nobody looked exactly like the character. Nobody cared.
When it came to picking what you’d be for Halloween in the ’90s, it was the same as it is now—whatever was big on TV or at the movies. (But obviously, there was better pop culture back then, too.)
Not that you need the reminder, but after extensive searching of our increasingly foggy memories (with some help from the internet), here are the most popular ’90s Halloween costumes:
- Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Leonardo, Donatello, Raphael, or Michelangelo, depending on which turtle spoke to your soul.
- ’90s Disney princesses. Jasmine, Belle, Ariel, and Pocahontas, all with a turtleneck or heavy coat underneath.
- Mighty Morphin Power Rangers. Every block had at least three Rangers after the show premiered in 1993.
- Ghostface from Scream. After 1996, that mask was everywhere, because that movie still kicks ass.
- The Spice Girls. Usually a group costume, with a lot of arguing over who got to be who.
- Freddy or Jason. For those who wanted a little more murderous intent mixed into their spooky.
- Batman. Thanks to Michael Keaton, Val Kilmer, George Clooney, and an absolute classic animated series.
- The classics were still alive (except for the undead, of course). We showed the OGs proper respect back then, so you’d see witches, vampires, mummies, Frankenstein’s monsters, ghosts, zombies, pirates, and skeletons.
Decorations were spooky, not 12-foot-tall coronary triggers
’90s Halloween decorations went for spooky and a little goofy, not huge and terrifying.
Today, there’s an arms race on every block: inflatables the size of minivans, motion-activated zombies that lunge at toddlers, and—since Home Depot launched it in 2020, when things were already scary enough—the roughly $300, 12-foot skeleton everyone calls Skelly. That thing is less a decoration than a plastic middle finger to your HOA. (And it’s how your neighbors end up with a coronary just taking out the garbage.)
Halloween in the ’90s worked on a smaller, cozier scale. Most of the ’90s Halloween decorations people remember fit in a single cardboard box in the garage. You might remember:
- Paper die-cuts. Jointed cardboard skeletons, black cats with arched backs, and grinning moons taped to the front window. Beistle, the company behind many of the classics, is still around.
- Blow molds. The glowing plastic jack-o’-lanterns and ghosts that lit up the porch with a single bulb inside.
- Gel window clings. Bats, pumpkins, and witches that stuck to the glass and somehow collected every speck of dust in the house.
- Lawn-bag pumpkins. Orange leaf bags with a jack-o’-lantern face, stuffed with actual yard leaves. Decorating and chores, all at once.
- Stretchy fake cobwebs. Pulled so thin over the bushes they looked less like cobwebs and more like a cotton-ball crime scene.
The most elaborate thing on the block was usually a garage haunted house run by the neighborhood dads, complete with a strobe light, a cassette of creaky-door sound effects, and a bowl of peeled-grape “eyeballs.” It was scary for about six seconds—and that was perfect.
Candy was different (and the full-size candy bar house was real)
’90s Halloween candy wasn’t totally different from today’s, but some of the best stuff is gone, and a few classics have quietly changed.
People often say candy back then used “real sugar.” That’s partly true. Most chocolate bars were sugar-based then and still are today. High-fructose corn syrup mostly took over in soda, not your Snickers. But what really changed is the lineup and some of the recipes.
The full-size candy bar house was the stuff of neighborhood legend. Everybody claimed to know one—whether they shared that information or not was another story. The rest of the ’90s Halloween candy haul was mostly fun-size bars, maybe something homemade if your neighborhood was tight-knit enough, plus a few treats that used to hit different:
- Butterfinger. Bart Simpson told us nobody better lay a finger on his. Ferrero bought the brand in 2018 and put out a new recipe in 2019. So if it tastes a little off, you’re not imagining it.
- Butterfinger BB’s. These were discontinued in 2006. It’s still too soon.
- Skittles with lime. Lime got swapped for green apple in 2013 and only came back in 2021. Eight lost years for fans of the original lineup.
- Wonder Ball. It was discontinued in 2007 and came back in 2016. But finding one now is its own scavenger hunt.
- Still around: Nerds, Fun Dip, Warheads, Ring Pops, Airheads, Smarties, and candy corn (which is either a blessing or a curse).
For a full rundown of what’s gone and what’s back, see our list of ’90s snacks we’d sell our souls to taste again.
The best ’90s Halloween movies still hold up
The ’90s Halloween movies you loved then are the ones you still rewatch every October, starting with Hocus Pocus.
The story of a virgin, a talking cat, and the Sanderson sisters hit theaters in July 1993, didn’t do great, and then turned into a classic thanks to years of October airings on Disney Channel and endless VHS rewinds. Thirty-some years later, that first airing of the season (or when it gets pushed into your streaming algo) is basically a holiday in and of itself.
Then there’s another witchy trifecta. The Witches (1990) had Mr. Bean in it, and it was still pure nightmare fuel. Nobody needed to see Anjelica Huston peel off her face, or watch a kid turn into a mouse. The Craft (1996) taught a generation that “we are the weirdos, mister” could be a whole vibe before we called anything a vibe. Practical Magic (1998) brought us the midnight margaritas scene, and had us under Sandy and Nicole’s spell of pure charisma. (We aren’t talking about Practical Magic 2.)
The rest of the ’90s Halloween movies worth a rewatch:
- The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993). Is it a Halloween movie or a Christmas movie? Yes.
- Casper (1995). The friendliest ghost, and your first CGI crush.
- Halloweentown (1998). The Disney Channel Original that made all of us want a grandma like Aggie.
- The Addams Family (1991) and Addams Family Values (1993). Christina Ricci’s Wednesday came long before the Netflix version.
- Scream (1996) and I Know What You Did Last Summer (1997). For when you graduated to sleepovers with the lights off.
- The Blair Witch Project and The Sixth Sense (both 1999). The decade went out on a slightly scarier note.
The TV side of ’90s Halloween was just as important. There were Treehouse of Horror episodes of The Simpsons, Nickelodeon’s Are You Afraid of the Dark?, the Goosebumps series, and whatever Halloween episode your favorite sitcom was airing that week. Many of these ’90s kids Halloween movies and shows that hooked us on being scared are streaming right now. (See the FAQ below for where to watch.)
Halloween books from the ’90s gave us our first real scares
The biggest Halloween books from the ’90s were Goosebumps, and it wasn’t close.
R.L. Stine kicked off the series with Welcome to Dead House in 1992 and then put out new titles at an almost unhinged pace, about one a month, for the rest of the decade. Those neon-dripping Tim Jacobus covers ran the Scholastic Book Fair. Night of the Living Dummy gave a whole generation a lifelong suspicion of ventriloquists.
The book fair also pushed the older kids toward R.L. Stine’s Fear Street series for teens and Christopher Pike’s YA thrillers. Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark wasn’t a ’90s book, but Stephen Gammell’s nightmare illustrations were passed around like contraband at ’90s sleepovers.
For anyone who snuck their parents’ paperbacks, Halloween in the ’90s also meant Stephen King. He was everywhere. The 1990 TV miniseries of IT, with Tim Curry as Pennywise, put in a lot of work to make people afraid of clowns. And King kept up the pace all decade, writing Needful Things (1991), Gerald’s Game and Dolores Claiborne (both 1992), Insomnia (1994), The Green Mile (released in monthly installments in 1996), and Bag of Bones (1998). Meanwhile, Anne Rice’s vampires got the big-screen treatment in 1994’s Interview with the Vampire, which sent a lot of people back to those books. And the new(ish) AMC series that revisits Louis and Lestat is definitely worth your time.
Reading by flashlight under the covers was, for many of us, the original doomscrolling. It was just a lot more fun.
How to bring ’90s Halloween back this year
The easiest way to have a ’90s Halloween is to pick a couple of things from this list and commit. You don’t have to do it all.
Here’s how to channel Halloween in the ’90s without a time machine:
- Host a ’90s-themed Halloween party. Make costumes mandatory, put the snacks in plastic pumpkin pails, and play Halloween movies on a loop in the background. Bonus points for busting out an actual VCR.
- Mix ’90s decorations into your current setup. Thrift stores, estate sales, Facebook Marketplace, eBay, and Etsy are full of vintage blow molds and paper die-cuts. Beistle still sells reproductions of its classic designs, and gel clings cost next to nothing.
- Hold a ’90s Halloween movie marathon. Start with Hocus Pocus and Halloweentown, move on to The Craft and Practical Magic, and save Scream for after the kids are asleep. (See the FAQ for where to stream each one.)
- Go ’90s with your costume. The best ’90s-themed Halloween costumes are easy to pull together from a thrift store. For ’90s movie Halloween costumes, try Cher from Clueless, Jack and Rose from Titanic, the Men in Black, Austin Powers, or a Ghostface mask. Maybe throw it back to Power Rangers or Ninja Turtles. The classic Halloween costumes work just as well now as they did back then, too.
- Eat old-school candy. Pick up some Fun Dip, Nerds, the ‘heads (both Air and War), and Ring Pops. Search out a Wonder Ball if you’re dedicated. And if you can, be the full-size candy bar house your neighborhood deserves. (Yes, we know what candy costs now.)
- Play a spooky ’90s Halloween playlist. Here’s a starter list:
- “This Is Halloween” (The Nightmare Before Christmas, 1993)
- Bette Midler’s “I Put a Spell on You” (Hocus Pocus, 1993)
- The Cranberries’ “Zombie” (1994)
- Rob Zombie’s “Dragula” (1998)
- Plus “Monster Mash,” “Ghostbusters,” and “Thriller,” because some traditions are worth keeping
The best part of ’90s Halloween came after trick-or-treating
Then came the best part of the night: you got home, peeled off the mask (finally), and dumped your pillowcase out on the living room carpet. You sorted everything into piles. You traded Milky Ways for 3 Musketeers with your siblings, and your parents took their “candy tax” in Reese’s. Then you put your favorite spooky VHS in the VCR or snuck a Goosebumps book and a flashlight under the covers. And you fell asleep with Fun Dip stains still on your fingers.
Honestly, we’d do it all again tomorrow. The only difference now is that the stomachache lasts three days. For more seasonal snack grief, check out the ’90s snacks we miss.
Quick answers about ’90s Halloween
How do you have a ’90s Halloween? Pick a ’90s costume (Power Rangers, Ghostface, the Spice Girls, or anyone from Clueless), decorate with paper die-cuts and blow molds, and hand out old-school candy like Fun Dip, Nerds, and Airheads. Then finish the night with a ’90s Halloween movie like Hocus Pocus or Scream and a spooky ’90s playlist.
Where can you watch ’90s Halloween movies? As of October 2026, Hocus Pocus, Halloweentown, and The Nightmare Before Christmas are on Disney+. Practical Magic and The Craft are on HBO Max, Casper is on Hulu, and Scream and The Addams Family (1991) are on Paramount+. Streaming lineups change basically all the time, so do a little research before you pop the corn for movie night.
Where can you buy ’90s Halloween decorations? Your best bets for vintage ’90s Halloween decorations are thrift stores, estate sales, Facebook Marketplace, eBay, and Etsy, especially for blow molds and Beistle paper die-cuts. Beistle still sells reproductions of its classic designs, and big-box stores sell gel window clings and lawn-bag pumpkins every fall.
Where can you buy ’90s Halloween candy? Lots of classic ’90s Halloween candy, like Nerds, Fun Dip, Warheads, Ring Pops, and Airheads, is still at any grocery store. For harder-to-find candy, try online retro candy shops, which sell nostalgia assortments. But some favorites, like Butterfinger BB’s, are gone for good.
What were the most popular ’90s Halloween costumes? The most popular Halloween costumes from the ’90s included pop culture favorites like the Power Rangers, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Disney princesses (Jasmine and Belle), Ghostface from Scream, the Spice Girls, Freddy and Jason, and Batman. And there were still lots of classics (vampires, ghosts, witches, etc.) pulled off with homemade costumes.
